Hosei University Manabu Sakaue's Lab.

Hosei Univ.
Keiei Gakkai
50th Aniversary

Referee Guidelines

Reviewers of APIRA 2013 Kobe are kindly asked to submit their reviews in the below format.

(Sample) Referee Report Form

Note: This form is just a sample for you to familiarize yourself with.

Referee (Your) Name:

Email Address:

Email Address (Confirm):

Paper Number you have refereed (e.g. K001):

Paper Title you have refereed:

Please choose your recommendation:
A: Accept
B: Accept subject to minor revision
C: Accept subject to major revision
D: Reject

Please rate the quality of the paper in the below aspects:
not at all to some extent to a great extent

1
2
3
4
5

Is the topic of the paper relevant for the APIRA community?:
not
at all		 to some
extent		 to a great
extent

1
2
3
4
5

Is the method(s) of the paper appropriate for the objective of the paper?:
not
at all		 to some
extent		 to a great
extent

1
2
3
4
5

Is the execution of the method(s) well?:
not
at all		 to some
extent		 to a great
extent

1
2
3
4
5

Is the finding(s) academically valuable?:
not
at all		 to some
extent		 to a great
extent

1
2
3
4
5

Is the implication convincing?:
not
at all		 to some
extent		 to a great
extent

1
2
3
4
5

Comments to the author, if any:

Comments only to the scientific committee, if any:

================